* Existing systems ** Hepburn *** Tables Entries marked with an asterisk (*) are irregular. Entries marked with two asterisks (**) are ambiguous as to the kana they represent. **** Gožùuon | o | e | u | i | a | | |--------+----+--------+--------+----+----| | o | e | u | i | a | Ø | | ko | ke | ku | ki | ka | k | | go | ge | gu | gi | ga | g | | so | se | su | shi* | sa | s | | zo | ze | zu** | ji* ** | za | z | | to | te | tsu* | chi* | ta | t | | do | de | zu* ** | ji* ** | da | d | | no | ne | nu | ni | na | n | | ho | he | fu* | hi | ha | h | | po | pe | pu | pi | pa | p | | bo | be | bu | bi | ba | b | | mo | me | mu | mi | ma | m | | yo | | yu | | ya | y | | ro | re | ru | ri | ra | r | | wo | we | | wi | wa | w | |--------+----+--------+--------+----+----| | n/n'/m | | | | | n' | **** Yòuon | yo | yu | ya | | |------+------+------+----| | kyo | kyu | kya | ki | | gyo | gyu | gya | gi | | sho | shu | sha | si | | jo** | ju** | ja** | zi | | cho | chu | cha | ti | | jo** | ju** | ja** | di | | nyo | nyu | nya | ni | | hyo | hyu | hya | hi | | pyo | pyu | pya | pi | | byo | byu | bya | bi | | myo | myu | mya | mi | | ryo | ryu | rya | ri | **** Extended/Foreign | o | e | u | i | a | | |----+------+----+----+----+---| | vo | ve | vu | vi | va | v | | | | | si | | s | | | | | zi | | z | | | she | | | | š | | | je** | | | | ž | | | | tu | ti | | t | | | | du | di | | d | | | che | | | | ť | | | je** | | | | ď | | | | hu | | | h | | fo | fe | | fi | fa | ꜧ | *** Defining features **** Attempts to aid the pronunciation of English-speakers by approximating differences from the stable consonants using English sounds. **** Uses macrons for long vowels. *** Flaws **** English-biased. **** Creates apparent grammatical irregularity. **** Does not relate irregular kana to their rows (e.g. ‘chi’ does not indicate its relationship to the t- row) **** Introduces ambiguity not seen in kana spelling: ži/ďi, oo/ou. **** The English sounds used to approximate the unstable consonants are actually further away from the real sound than the stable consonants they replace. **** Fails to distinguish pitch-accent pairs. **** Does not standardise extended/foreign sequences; ambiguity results from e.g. wi vs. ẇi. ** Kunrei/Nihon *** Tables **** Gožùuon | o | e | u | i | a | | |--------+----+----+----+----+----| | o | e | u | i | a | Ø | | ko | ke | ku | ki | ka | k | | go | ge | gu | gi | ga | g | | so | se | su | si | sa | s | | zo | ze | zu | zi | za | z | | to | te | tu | ti | ta | t | | do | de | du | di | da | d | | no | ne | nu | ni | na | n | | ho | he | hu | hi | ha | h | | po | pe | pu | pi | pa | p | | bo | be | bu | bi | ba | b | | mo | me | mu | mi | ma | m | | yo | | yu | | ya | y | | ro | re | ru | ri | ra | r | | wo | we | | wi | wa | w | |--------+----+----+----+----+----| | n/n' | | | | | n' | **** Yòuon | yo | yu | ya | | |-----+-----+-----+----| | kyo | kyu | kya | ki | | gyo | gyu | gya | gi | | syo | syu | sya | si | | zyo | zyu | zya | zi | | tyo | tyu | tya | ti | | dyo | dyu | dya | di | | nyo | nyu | nya | ni | | hyo | hyu | hya | hi | | pyo | pyu | pya | pi | | byo | byu | bya | bi | | myo | myu | mya | mi | | ryo | ryu | rya | ri | **** Extended/Foreign | o | e | u | i | a | | |----+-----+----+----+----+---| | vo | ve | vu | vi | va | v | | | | | | | s | | | | | | | z | | | sye | | | | š | | | zye | | | | ž | | | | | | | t | | | | | | | d | | | tye | | | | ť | | | dye | | | | ď | | | | | | | h | | | | | | | ꜧ | *** Defining features **** Aims to preserve the regularity of kana with no ambiguity. **** Uses circumflexes for long vowels. *** Flaws **** Does not indicate irregular pronunciations at all. **** Introduces ambiguity not seen in kana spelling: oo/ou. **** Fails to distinguish pitch-accent pairs. **** Has very few extended/foreign sequences, and makes assigning them difficult (e.g. ꜧa cannot be written ‘ha’ by analogue with ‘hu’ because ‘ha’ is ha) ** JSL ** Wa-puro * Proposed system ** Table | N\ | w | r | y | m | b | p | h | n | d | t | z | s | g | k | Ø | v | u | i | | n' | wa | ra | ya | ma | ba | pa | ha | na | da | ta | za | sa | ga | ka | a | va | ẇa (うぁ) | ẏa | | | wi | ri | | mi | bi | pi | hi | ni | ďi* | ťi* | ži* | ši* | gi | ki | i | vi | ẇi (うぃ) | ẏi | | | wu | ru | yu | mu | bu | pu | ꜧu* | nu | ɗu* | ƭu* | zu | su | gu | ku | u | vu | ẇu (うぅ) | ẏu | | | we | re | | me | be | pe | he | ne | de | te | ze | se | ge | ke | e | ve | ẇe (うぇ) | ẏe | | | wo | ro | yo | mo | bo | po | ho | no | do | to | zo | so | go | ko | o | vo | ẇo (うぉ) | ẏo | ** Features *** n' is always n' regardless of position (ZÀBON', oǹ'pu, hon'yàku) *** Long vowels: **** Macron for katakana with ťouon (APĀTO, PĀTĪ, but EIZU, OOUNAGI) **** Normal spelling otherwise (ooi, oosaka, sòuai) **** Diæresis when no assimilation occurs (omòü, òü) *** Tone drop: **** Grave accent on vowel or n *** Katakana: **** Caps *** Irregularities: **** Written as per kana (ha, he) -- UNHAPPY *** ASCII rendition: **** caron becomes following j (sji, tji, dji, djuu) **** upper hook becomes following s/z (tsu, dzu) **** lower hook becomes \ (h\u) **** diæresis becomes hyphen (o`-u) **** grave accent becomes following backtick (so`uai) **** macron becomes following underscore (apa_to) -- UNHAPPY